Neha Sharma, a 30-year-old software engineer in Bengaluru buying her first car, had Rs. 10 lakh, a shortlist of two and a quotation sheet she could not read. The car she picked was advertised at Rs. 9.31 lakh. The number at the bottom of the dealer's page said Rs. 11.42 lakh. Between them sat fourteen cost items, a few she recognised, most she did not and one labelled simply "handling". The salesperson called the whole page standard. She wanted to know which of those cost components she was legally obliged to pay and which she was merely expected to.
Ex-showroom price is what the manufacturer and dealer charge for the car itself. On-road price is that figure plus road tax, registration and insurance and it usually runs 12 to 20 per cent higher depending on where you register. Road tax is the largest addition and your state sets it, not the carmaker. Insurance is the one cost you can shop for independently. Anything a dealer adds beyond that deserves a question.
What the advertised number actually covers
The price in the advertisement has three things inside it. The factory cost of the car, the Goods and Services Tax and the dealer's profit margin.
That margin matters more than buyers realise, because the cost of trucking the car from factory to showroom already sits inside it. When a quotation lists "handling" or "logistics" as a separate charge further down the page, the dealer is asking you to pay twice for something the ex-showroom price already covers. Ask what it buys. The answers tend to get vague.
What the advertised price never includes is the three things that make the car legal to drive: registration, road tax and insurance.
Good to know: GST rates on cars were revised in September 2025, which lowered ex-showroom prices across the small-car segment. That reduction quietly compounded, because road tax is charged as a percentage of ex-showroom price, so a lower base price produced a smaller tax bill on top of it.
Where the extra lakh goes
Every Rupee between the two numbers belongs to someone specific. Knowing who set each charge tells you instantly whether it is worth arguing about.
Component | Who sets it | Roughly, on a Rs. 10 lakh car | Can you refuse it? |
|---|---|---|---|
Road tax | Your state government | Rs. 40,000 to Rs. 1.8 lakh | No |
Registration fee | Central government | Rs. 600, flat nationwide | No |
HSRP number plate | State-approved vendor | A few hundred Rupees | No |
FASTag | Mandatory for new vehicles | Around Rs. 500 | No |
Hypothecation entry | RTO, only if financed | About Rs. 1,500 | No, if you take a loan |
Tax Collected at Source | Income Tax Department | 1%, only above Rs. 10 lakh ex-showroom | No, but you get it back |
Insurance | Your insurer, partly IRDAI | Varies widely | Partly, you choose the insurer |
Accessories, extended warranty, maintenance packages | Dealer | Whatever you agree to | Yes, entirely optional |
Handling or logistics | Dealer | Varies | Question it |
Read the right-hand column before the amounts. The first six cost components belong to the government and no negotiation can move them. Everything below is shoppable or optional, which is where a first-time buyer's opportunity to negotiate actually lives.
One component on that list is not a cost at all. Tax Collected at Source applies only when the ex-showroom price crosses Rs. 10 lakh and it is an advance against your income tax rather than a fee, so you claim it back when you file your return. On a Rs. 15 lakh car, that is Rs. 15,000 most buyers write off and never reclaim.
Why does the same car cost far more in Bengaluru than in Delhi
Here is where published guides mislead people, including some who should know better. Road tax is not two or three per cent of your car's price. It runs from roughly 2.5 per cent in the most cost-effective union territories to over 20 per cent in the most expensive states and it is the largest single cost between the two numbers.
Karnataka sits near the top of that range. Delhi sits far below it. On the same Rs. 12 lakh car the gap alone can pass Rs. 80,000, which is why Neha's Bengaluru quotation looked nothing like the figure her cousin quoted from Delhi. Neither dealer was cheating. They were quoting different state governments.
Three things follow and they change what you do at the desk.
Road tax is calculated on the full ex-showroom price, before any dealer discount. A Rs. 30,000 festive discount reduces what you pay the dealer and reduces your road tax by nothing at all.
It is a one-time payment covering roughly fifteen years, so it is a purchase cost rather than a running cost and it deserves a place in your budget rather than a surprise at the end of it.
Many states waive or heavily reduce it on electric vehicles, which can quietly close the price gap between an EV and its petrol equivalent.
Rates, slabs and cesses vary by state, by fuel type and by price band and states revise them without much warning. Check yours on the Parivahan portal or your state transport department's site before you accept any quotation as final.
Which cost components should you question
Work down the dealer's page and sort it into three sections.
Non-negotiable covers road tax, registration, HSRP, FASTag and hypothecation if you have a loan. Pay these and move on.
Shoppable means insurance is covered below.
Optional is everything else. Accessories, extended warranty, annual maintenance packages and any charge labelled handling all belong here. Dealers present them as part of the on-road price because presentation is the whole trick. Ask for the quotation with every optional cost removed, then add back only what you want. Neha's fourteen cost components became nine.
Good to know: An extended warranty deserves evaluation on its own merits rather than being accepted at the desk. If you drive very little, the standard warranty may outlast your usage anyway.
Why does the insurance cost look so large on a new car?
Most first-time buyers expect one year of insurance and see a number that looks like three. That is because it is.
Every new private car in India must carry three years of third-party cover from the day it is registered, so the dealer's quotation bundles three years of third-party liability with one year of own-damage cover. The third-party portion is priced by IRDAI and is therefore identical at every insurer in the country. Nobody can discount it and nobody can charge you more for it.
The own-damage portion varies by insurer, by city, by the Insured Declared Value and by the add-ons you accept and it is where the money in that cost actually moves. A new car's IDV sits close to its ex-showroom price in year one, which is exactly when zero depreciation earns its keep and when the premium is highest.
Deciding between the dealer's insurance and your own policy? Take the dealer's if convenience outweighs the difference and you have compared the own-damage component against at least one outside quote. Buy your own if you want to choose the insurer, the IDV and the add-ons yourself, which is your right regardless of what the dealer implies. The third-party portion costs the same either way, so you are only ever comparing the own-damage half.
Zurich Kotak General Insurance Company (India) Limited offers comprehensive plans with add-ons relevant to new cars and the policy wording sets out exactly what each add-on covers, subject to policy terms.
Conclusion
Neha did three things before signing, none of which took longer than an afternoon. She asked for the quotation with every optional cost stripped out, looked up Karnataka's road tax slab herself instead of trusting the sheet and compared the own-damage half of the insurance against an independent quote. Her final number came down without a single argument about the car's price, which was never the negotiable part anyway.
Do the same at your own desk. Separate what the government charges from what the dealer suggests, treat the ex-showroom figure as the start of the conversation rather than the end of it and budget against the only number that ever mattered, which is the one you actually hand over.
Get a Car Insurance Quote in 60 seconds
Frequently asked questions
Why is the on-road price so much higher than the advertised price?
The on-road price is higher because the advertised price reflects only the cost of the car itself. Road tax, registration charges, mandatory insurance and any dealer-added extras sit on top of that and together they may add 12 to 20% to the final amount payable. Road tax is usually the largest component of this difference and it depends entirely on the state where you register the vehicle.
Can I get a discount on the ex-showroom price?
Rarely in a direct sense, since manufacturers set it. Dealers discount the on-road total instead, through exchange bonuses, corporate offers and festive schemes. Those discounts do not reduce your road tax, which is calculated on the full ex-showroom price regardless.
Is the 1% TCS on cars an extra tax I lose?
No. Tax Collected at Source applies only when the ex-showroom price exceeds Rs. 10 lakh and it is an advance against your income tax liability, so you adjust it when filing your return. Keep the dealer's TCS certificate safely.
Do I have to buy insurance from the car dealer?
No. You may buy your motor insurance from any insurer you choose. The three-year third-party premium is fixed by IRDAI and identical everywhere, but own-damage premiums and add-ons vary between insurers, so comparing that portion is worthwhile.
